How about a flavor that has everything but the kitchen sink? Cookie dough, fudge, brownie batter, peanut butter swirls (or Speculoos OR Trader Joe's Cookie Butter), caramel, pretzels, peanuts or almonds. Throw some cake batter in there too! Just an idea! I've never been to your store b/c I live in Pittsburgh but it looks ah-mazing and I hope to visit one day!!! Best of luck to you!